Welcome

This is a collection of program notes, lectures and other writings by Dr. Laurence R. Taylor (1937-2004). Most of them were written for the Princeton Symphony and Opera Festival of New Jersey but some were for the Newtown Chamber Orchestra and Greater Princeton Youth Orchestra as well as some recitals. I am trying to get these online as fast as possible. There will be some strange formatting. Whenever you see a phrase in ALL CAPS he meant italics. Somehow pressing that little i button was too much trouble :) I will edit them to make that change when time allows. Suggestions are also welcome. Also you will find that LRT used British orthography even though he lived most of his life in New Jersey. Those spellings will remain since in his words "[I have had a] Close lifelong with British musical life – with annual return visits to refresh the soul by rejoining British friends, and drinking in a wide range of musical life there."


You may reprint any of the materials posted here for no charge as long as credit is given in the printed material to Laurence R. Taylor. I'd be delighted to receive a copy too.

Gene De Lisa


Friday, January 1, 1999

Vivaldi: The Four Seasons: Four Concerti for Violin, Strings and Continuo, Op. 8, Nos. 1-4

The Four Seasons: Four Concerti for Violin, Strings and Continuo, Op. 8, Nos. 1-4

Antonio Vivaldi
(1678-1741)

Any music lover shopping for recordings of Baroque music, seeing the display bins AWASH with the works of Antonio Vivaldi, would probably be amazed to learn that before the 1950s hardly any of the Venetian master’s works were printed or performed---much less recorded! A reference to the 1950s is significant, because if any factor helps to explain the startling revival of interest in Vivaldi’s music, it may well be the invention of the long-playing record. (That has also been the case with a surprising number of major composers who only recently have become central to the repertoire---Berlioz , Bruckner and Mahler are remarkable instances. Some other figures remained fairly marginal to the concert world until the late 20th century, including Handel, Haydn, Schubert and Wolf. Others were virtually unknown, for example Claudio Monteverdi . who was hardly ever heard before Nadia Boulanger’s pioneering recording of 1937.)

The eclipse of Antonio Vivaldi’s vast body of works is quite inexplicable. Although it is often claimed that J. S. Bach’s music had disappeared following his death, in fact a number of important musicians championed his compositions even before the so-called “Bach Revival” in the 19th century. But Vivaldi, who, unlike Bach, attained international fame in his lifetime, fell into an obscurity which only began to disperse in the early 20th century. One element in a reawakening of interest in Vivaldi was actually a by-product of Bach scholarship: the discovery of the strong influence of Vivaldi upon J. S. Bach, which prompted some specialists in Baroque music to trace that influence back to its source.

Antonio Vivaldi, whose father was a professional musician, was born in Venice, received early training as a violinist, and in his teens began studies for the priesthood. He was ordained at the age of 25, but while nominally a clergyman all his life, never said mass, rather devoting himself to a career as a violinist and composer. In 1703 he was appointed MAESTRO DI VIOLINO at the Pio Ospedale della Pieta in Venice, a convent school for orphaned and abandoned girls. He was in charge of instruction in string instruments, and directed the school orchestra, for which he composed a great deal of his earlier music. This orchestra soon became a great tourist attraction in Venice. Guidebooks of the day urged visitors to attend concerts presented by the school orchestra, to marvel at the sight of an orchestra composed of teen-aged girls dressed in miniature nun’s habits, playing at a remarkable level of professionalism. (Those who know the Bay Area Women’s Orchestra, or are old enough to remember Phil Spitalny’s “All-Girl Orchestra,” may be surprised to learn that indeed nothing is new under the sun!) Not surprisingly for a native of Venice, Vivaldi moved on to a successful career composing operas: at least 46 are known by title, although many have been lost. In everything he did there was great abundance, vivacity of tone, brilliant effects, and a pronounced gift for making money----and wasting it. (Vivaldi was to die penniless while visiting Vienna in 1741, engaged in yet another self-promotion scheme.) In an output of some 1000 compositions there are about 500 concerti, as well as a great quantity of church music, oratorios, cantatas, and sonatas of every description. Best known are the concerti, including about 250 for solo violin, dozens

for cello, bassoon, flute, oboe, and others composed for virtually every instrument this side of comb-and-waxed-paper!

To this day the world thinks of Vivaldi mostly in terms of his concertos----symbolized by the unfair, if delicious comment that “Vivaldi composed four concertos six hundred times.” The best reply to such a jibe is to point to the several dozen Vivaldi concerti which J. S. Bach saw fit to arrange for keyboard instruments, as well as his glittering transcription for four harpsichords and orchestra of Vivaldi’s Concerto for 4 violins, Op. 3, No. 11.

Nothing comes close to the popularity which has been won by “The Four Seasons”: Vivaldi’s
Op. 8, Nos. 1-4. The writer of these notes can remember when virtually the only available recording of the work was a galumphing performance by John Corigliano and the New York Philharmonic. At last count Vivaldi fanciers now have a choice of ONE HUNDRED THIRTEEN DIFFERENT RECORDINGS!!!! This is cause for sour grapes on the part of some high-minded music lovers. In London, for example, where for generations the cash-cow perennial in the concert business has been the 1812 Overture (“with cannon and mortar effects”), the “Seasons” has joined its company as a lure for audiences of tourists and families with children. But to anyone with an open mind a good performance of the Seasons cannot but explain this popularity.

Indeed, the composition was popular from the start. While the “Seasons” was a recurring theme in 17th century Italian and French ballets and stage spectacles, Vivaldi was probably the first composer to deal with the subject in a purely instrumental terms. Part of the appeal of his work lies in its suggestive “program” elements (which are spelled out in sonnets which accompany each concerto in turn), but even more in the brilliance and energy so characteristic of all of the composer’s best work. A success when first performed in 1725, the celebrated CONCERTS SPIRITUELS introduced the set of concertos to Paris audiences in 1728, becoming a favourite in France throughout the 18th century. There is even a slender thread connecting Vivaldi’s work with the world of Josef Haydn, for the entire Op. 8 collection of 12 concerti (which include the Four Seasons) was dedicated to Count Morzin, of the family who would employ Haydn in the early stage of his career.

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

While conforming to most of the conventional structural patterns of the day, these compositions are surprisingly “programmatic” in character, illustrative of the imagery and general tone expressed in the “Sonetti Dimostrativi” (“Demonstrative Sonnets”), which were printed at the head of each concerto in turn, poems possibly penned by Vivaldi himself. These not only lay out a variety of pictorial elements which are depicted in the music, but are even set out line by line in the printed score at appropriate points.

Concerto No. 1 in E Major, “Spring.” Following the confident, rhythmically sturdy opening RITORNELLO, the solo violin evokes the sound of singing birds, joined in the effort by two solo violins from the orchestra. Soloist and orchestra together portray the murmuring streams and gentle breezes in pulsing repeated pairs of notes, followed by a sudden brief shower (sweeping scale patterns, rapid, excited triplets.) Following the poem, things quiet down, the birds sing as before, and a concluding phrase from the RITORNELLO rounds out the movement. The second movement (marked LARGO, E PIANISSIMO SEMPRE) paints a charming scene in which the rustling of the leaves is heard (in the murmuring rhythmic figure in the violins), the goatherd sleeps (solo violin heard in a lyrical of tender simplicity), with his faithful dog nearby (barking sounds in the violas, marked “always loud and rasping”!) The lively finale is marked “Danza pastorale” – a shepherd’s dance. The solo episodes are more relaxed than dramatic, the overall tone festive and good-natured.

Concerto No. 2 in G Minor, “Summer.” This most original and theatrical of the concerti finds Vivaldi making the most of opportunities for virtuoso writing for soloist and orchestra alike, in a vivid pictorial display inspired by the dramatic elements set out in the poem. The main elements of the first movement follow a quite eccentric structural plan: A – B – A – C – D – A – E – B. While “A” might be considered a conventional RITORNELLO, it is quite unlike almost any other one to be found: a quiet, hesitant introductory passage intended to portray the sluggish atmosphere of the summer heat. In “B” the voice of the cuckoo is heard (after a fashion), the typical “cuckoo” call imbedded in bustling solo violin passagework. After a bit of “A” is heard again, “C” brings in the song of the turtledove and the goldfinch, the orchestra (in soft rapid triplets) describing the gentle southern breezes. This is suddenly swept aside by the violent blasts of the north wind (“D”) in a startling, frenzied outburst in the orchestra. A fragment of “A” cools things down, and in the “E” episode the shepherd (a sensitive soul) sheds tears of fear and anxiety. The movement’s conclusion (a return of the “B” section), While not actually dictated by the poem, Vivaldi follows his dramatic instincts to swing the movement to a conclusion in a bold and decisive manner. The slow movement portrays the frightened shepherd (heard in sweet but fearful lyrical phrases in the solo violin) wracked with fear in the presence of blasts of thunder and flashing lightning (heard in the orchestra.) The finale gives Vivaldi a glorious excuse go even one better in portraying Mother Nature in full tempestuous majesty. While the soloist has moments to be heard above the fray, the movement is notable as a splendid early example of orchestral virtuosity, creating a sense of excitement which can stand comparison with later storm in Beethoven, Berlioz and Richard Strauss.

Concerto No. 3 in F Major, “Autumn.” The opening movement is the musical equivalent of a scene by Breughel, capturing the mood of sturdy peasant merry-making at harvest time, with dancing, drinking to excess and ultimate falling into slumber. The episodes for solo violin illustrate a gradual transition from boisterous enjoyment to inevitable fatigue and exhaustion. The slow movement is an unexpectedly poetic piece of tone-painting, illustrating the “agreeableness of sweet sleep” described in the poem: sleep following upon the enjoyable excesses of drink. The rowdy pleasures of the chase set the tone for the finale, evocative of the countryside, the huntsmen, dogs, guns and cruel high spirits. The soloist expresses the energy and exhilaration of the riders, as well as the inevitable exhaustion and death of the quarry.

Concerto No. 4 in F Minor, “Winter” The first movement, marked ALLEGRO NON MOLTO (i. e., quick, but not much), opens with a memorable tonal evocation of the winter cold…. The “wild winds” are heard in the solo violin, while in the orchestra can be heard “stamping frozen feet.” The solo episodes express the physical discomforts of cold and wind, even including the portrayal of chattering of teeth at one point. The LARGO slow movement is a moment of warmth and shelter at a welcoming fireside, captured in an unbroken lyrical outpouring in the solo violin against the background of ticking PIZZICATO violins and murmuring lower strings. (Some ears may detect a delightful “pre-echo” of “April Showers,” quite appropriate in these frosty circumstances!) The final movement opens with descriptions of walking on icy ground. From a hushed, tentative beginning, Vivaldi is inspired by the sonnet’s reference to winds “loosed in battle” to press on to a forceful, emphatic conclusion. As the poem say, “such is winter, these are joys it brings.”

Vaughan Williams: Symphony No. 8 in D Minor: Scherzo Alla Marcia

Symphony No. 8 in D Minor: Scherzo Alla Marcia

Ralph Vaughan Williams (1872-1958)


As with the Russians, the symphony became a “big statement” for 20th century English composers, who, following a long period of relative musical eclipse (following the age of William Boyce), were bringing about the revival of English music, producing a rich harvest of symphonies by such composers as Elgar, Bax, Brian, Walton, Bliss, Britten, and Tippett. Most impressive of all were the nine symphonies of Vaughan Williams, extending from the massive choral “Sea Symphony” of 1910 to the haunting Ninth Symphony of 1958. The Eight (1956) is the most youthful and relaxed of the set, amazingly inventive in its exploration of instrumental colour for a composer nearly 84 years of age. Opening with a variations movement for full orchestra, there follows an a Scherzo movement for winds and brass, a slow movement for strings alone, and a rambunctious concluding Toccata for full orchestra using (as the composer put it) “all the spiels and gongs” of the percussion section.

Marked “Alla Marcia,” the Scherzo opens with spiky little tune coiling through the bassoons against a prickly muted brass background, soon leading to a contrasting trumpet solo, which in its vinegary way seems evocative of well-remembered music heard on Sundays afternoons by a brass band playing in a park. The main tune rounds out the Scherzo section, with the winds skirling away with great energy, the music full of sharply-etched contours, bright colours and rhythmic swagger. The Trio is a brief, loping, folksong-like melody, the winds taking the lead against soft punctuation in the trumpets. The Scherzo section returns, boiled down to an echo of its earlier form, sinking into a hush, ending with a fingersnap.

GPYO concert

Shostakovich : Symphony No. 5 in D Minor, Op. 47: Finale

Symphony No. 5 in D Minor, Op. 47: Finale

Dmitri Shostakovich (1906-1975)


Perhaps no important composer in the history of music was more swept up in the political and social upheavals of his lifetime than Dmitri Shostakovich. A witness to the Bolshevik Revolution fought in the streets of his native Saint Petersburg, as a precocious boy of 19 Shostakovich sprang to international fame overnight with the appearance of his First Symphony, and soon was treated as the darling of the new Soviet state, reach a highpoint of brilliant success at the age of 28 with his opera Lady Macbeth Of Mtsensk, which was performed around the world, But this triumph was swept away when Josef Stalin attended a performance of the opera, and was outraged by the music’s dissonant style, as well as its raw emotion and unbridled eroticism. Within a few days Pravda published a furious attack upon the opera (probably written by Stalin himself), and the work was withdrawn immediately, not to be heard again anywhere for nearly 30 years. A powerful Fourth Symphony, was also withdrawn without a public performance. The young composer quietly waited for a knock at the door in the middle of the night----the mid-1930s was the age of the worst Stalinist terror. After a couple years spent in near-seclusion, Shostakovich surfaced with a 5th Symphony, which turned out to be the triumph of the composer’s life. The authorities were delighted, blithely unaware of the irony underlying the composer’s own description of the work as “a Soviet artist’s reply to justified criticism,” and for years the symphony was proclaimed to be the embodiment of Soviet ideals. But years later, Shostakovich declared that this was all a façade---the entire work was a long cry of pain and protest. Speaking of the outwardly festive character of the finale, Shostakovich said bitterly, “it’s as if someone were beating you with a stick and saying, ‘Your business is rejoicing, your business is rejoice,” and you rise, shaky, and go marching off, muttering, ‘Our business is rejoicing, our business is rejoicing.’”

Nevertheless. the finale of the symphony stands as a 20th century example of the kind of dazzling Russian folk idiom is heard in the fast finales of Tchaikovsky’s symphonies. The opening is unforgettable: over pounding drumbeats, the brass thunders out the main theme, the sort of strident tune which (despite the composer’s terrible inner rage at his situation) cannot but seem utterly “Soviet” in character!) This sweeps on to a towering climax, there emerges a secondary theme of yearning and pleading tenderness. For all the outward “celebratory” character of the music, alert ears will detect a tension and stress lying just beneath the surface, even as the music attains a state of glassy, eerie calm, mostly confined to the strings of the orchestra. The drumbeat stealthily returns, and the music returns to the power and “public festival” mood of the opening. Yet the main theme doesn’t return in its original form, now heard in longer notes, more forceful, even menacing, as the music presses on to emerge in the brilliant glare of the coda: a blaze of thundering drumbeats, repeated notes in the strings, brass fanfares. The Soviet authorities heard it as a paean of praise to the state – audiences can find it a thrilling deluge of instrumental colour – attentive ears will understand the meaning of that astonishing description given by the composer himself.

GPYO concert

Tchaikovsky : Symphony No. 4 in F Minor, Op. 36: Andantino

Symphony No. 4 in F Minor, Op. 36: Andantino

Piotr Illyich Tchaikovsky (1840-1893)


When Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov and Tchaikovsky composed the first important Russian symphonies in the same year (1866), their achievement seemed to be an important symbolic step in defining a national musical identity. Rimsky’s symphonies are now rarely heard, but those of Tchaikovsky’s are performed, the final three (Nos. 4-6) being especially popular. The Fourth Symphony (1878) is a powerful, dramatic work, exhibiting the great extremes of emotional expression so characteristic of Tchaikovsky.

Marked In Modo Di Canzone (“in the manner of a song”) the slow movement is quite Russian in character, with folksong-like melodies in which a handful of notes are repeated and extended in a plaintive, pleading manner. This is heard in the opening theme, given to a bassoon, passed on to the cellos, followed by a richly-textured contrasting melody in the strings. After swelling to a climax, the initial theme returns in the violins, decorated by a Scherzando counter-melody in the upper winds, rounded out by the return of the fuller sonorities of the contrasting theme. Unexpectedly the tempo quickens, and a march-like tune appears in then clarinets and bassoons, also typically “Russian” in its melodic contours. After the dark and pessimistic tone of the first part of the movement, this is brighter and spirited, soon reaching a fullness of sonority and emotional expressivity.

The music settles back to a return of the opening section, the principal theme now in the violins over a Pizzicato accompaniment, with a dance-like overlay of filigree patterns in the winds. The contrasting theme is heard again, leading to a Coda in which the principal theme is heard for a last time in the bassoon, the music passing into silence.

GPYO concert

Mozart: Symphony No. 39 in E-flat Major, K. 543: Minuet

Symphony No. 39 in E-flat Major, K. 543: Minuet

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791)

Written while still in his teens, Mozart’s first couple dozen symphonies are brief, charming, pieces, full of interesting details which set them apart from the run-of-the-mill Italian Sinfonias on which they were modeled. Sometimes a darker, probing character appears out of nowhere, as in the stirring, turbulent Symphony in G Minor (No. 25), which looks ahead to the famous 40th Symphony written in the same key. No. 25 and the serene 29th Symphony in A Major are the most popular of the earlier symphonies. An unbroken string of wonderful symphonies, serious in tone, intricate and expansive in structure, vivid in orchestral coloration, begins with No. 33. The truly great Mozart symphonies lead off with No. 38 in D Major, the “Prague” Symphony, composed around the same time as Don Giovanni, and a year later (1788), come the amazing final three symphonies, composed within the space of barely six weeks. These works are remarkably contrasted in key, instrumentation and mood. No. 41, majestic and festive, No. 40 stormy, restless and inward-turning, and the 39th Symphony warm and expansive in keeping with all of Mozart’s music composed in E-flat Major, a key he especially prized. With this work we move from the “quasi-symphony” of Boyce to the real McCoy: four movements, the outer ones fast and brilliant, enclosing a lyrical slow movement and hearty minuet movement. The Minuet shows Mozart in his most endearing popular vein, with a hearty initial minuet section followed by an oompah trio straight out of a tavern, suggestive of the season of the “Heuriger” [Spring wine] so typical of Viennese life.

GPYO concert

Boyce : Symphony No. 5 in D Major

Symphony No. 5 in D Major

William Boyce (1711-1779)

William Boyce was an prominent figure in English music in the years following the heyday of George Frideric Handel, holding holding such public posts as Composer to the Chapel Royal and Master of the King’s Music. Working in a period of transition, when the conventions of Baroque music were morphing+ into the early stages of the Classical age, Boyce’s “Eight Symphonys” [sic] had little to do with the Italian opera SINFONIA of the day, rather hearkening back to an earlier use of the word , when instrumental interludes in Baroque choral music were commonly labelled as “symphonies.”

The 5th Symphony is a compact work in three movement, rather reminiscent of the vigorous orchestral style of Handel, and exhibiting a breezy charm and forthright “English” spirit typical of Boyce. The weighty opening movement seems to have strayed in from the world of the orchestral suite, being a "French Overture," a musical structure familiar from the Overtures to many of Handel’s oratorios and operas, a familiar example being the “Ouverture” to Messiah. This first movement is indeed a brilliant, Handelian affair, with an opening section with fanfare interjections from trumpets and drums, and brilliant passages in the strings, followed by a sturdy fugue notable for its rhythmic vitality and cheerful spirit. The second movement is a neat and elegant interlude with an easy-going stride, featuring the oboes and strings. The concluding Minuetto is a sprightly dance finale, rather quicker than the kind of minuets heard later in Haydn and Mozart, bringing the symphony to a good-humoured conclusion.



GPYO

Tuesday, December 22, 1998

Lieder – Schubert: Some background.

Lieder – Schubert: Some background.

For all the many lovely songs composed by Bach, Handel, Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven, it remains true to say that the great age of Lieder composition was ushered in with the work of Franz Schubert, whose first great songs were written when he was a teenager. Schubert lived in a period of remarkable social and artistic change in central Europe, especially notable for an emerging middle class which increasingly replaced the church and aristocracy as the dominant factors in the world of music. Concert societies began to be organized, and public concert halls became a source of pride in prosperous 19th century city life. But there was music in the domestic sphere as well, seen in the growth of “Hausmusik”: music played and sung by family members, or heard as part of entertainment in the social occasions typical of the day. A key factor was the presence in the parlour of that most impressive article of furniture, a lovingly-polished PIANO, indispensable for music making, and a status symbol rather akin to a color television in homes in our century. Composers (and publishers) were not slow in responding to a promising market, resulting in a flood of music for piano (with piano duets especially popular), songs and chamber music appropriate for amateur performers. It is quite significant Franz Schubert, who only ONCE would hear a professional concert of his works in his short life, focused much of his activities upon the private gatherings of friends and admirers (the so-called “Schubertiads”) where his chamber music, piano music and songs were performed and received with enthusiasm. Around the same time the great burst of Romantic literature found an international audience for the works of Byron and Sir Walter Scott, while on the heels of Goethe and Schiller the German-speaking world embraced the works of figures such as Heine, Eichendorff and Grillparzer. In a way unique to the early Romantic age, these trends in music and literature came together in the work of Schubert, who composed some 600 songs, sometimes setting the words of poets such as Goethe and Heine, in other cases transmuting the serviceable (if second-rate) work of lesser poets into the greatest lyrical expression ever known. There are every sort of song: simple folk like ditties such as “Heiden Röslein, ” expansive songs lasting a quarter hour, songs in Italian, French, even songs in which other instruments take part, as in his very last composition, “Der Hirt auf dem Felsen, ” [“The Shepherd on the Rock”] written for voice, clarinet and piano. The significance of the songs can be seen in the composer’s use of several of them in some of his greatest works: “Trout” Quintet, “Death and Maiden” Quartet, “Wanderer” Fantasy for piano. Probably the most miraculous aspect of Schubert’s career is that “mere songs, ” music ostensibly inspired by casual social entertainment, should lead to the astonishing accomplishment of his song cycles, Schöne Müllerin and Winterreise. But even the least of the 600 Lieder have much to offer----Brahms, as is well-remembered, said that something could be learned from studying each and every one of them.